Predictika · Jobs released to a machine by an AI planning agent

An AI planning agent's job release to a machine, checked before it reaches the machine

An AI production-planning agent picks the next job and releases it to a machine, using the plant's own records: the machine and its calibration and maintenance, the tools loaded, the operator and shift, the fixture, the program and the material certification. Before it goes out, the agent sends the release to Predictika, which checks it against a declarative model of what those records say and returns a verdict, every reason and the figures it computed.

Scope: Releasing one job to one machine at a precision job shop: a 3-axis mill, a 5-axis mill, a CNC lathe and a laser cutter; what the machine can take and cut, calibration, tool life, maintenance, operator, shift, program, fixture and certification. See everything this validator covers

This validator models one job release to one machine at a fictional precision job shop, not just the scenarios shown below. The shop, its machines and its rules are fictional stand-ins for what a real plant keeps in its machine capability sheets, calibration and maintenance records, tool-life data and quality procedures. It is an example policy, not a safety certification.

  • What the machine can take — each of the four machines has a longest part, a heaviest part, a number of axes and a tightest tolerance it holds; titanium runs only on the 5-axis mill and the lathe.
  • Whether the machine is fit for the job — the calibration age is checked against a limit that is shorter when the tolerance is tight; the tools loaded must last the whole run; preventive maintenance falling due during the run goes to the maintenance supervisor.
  • Who runs it and how — the operator's level must meet what the machine needs; a program that has never run releases one proof part only and never runs unattended; a lights-out run over six hours, and a release that takes the machine from a running job, go to a person.
  • What the job needs on hand — the fixture at the machine, and the material certification on file for medical and aerospace work. The run time the release states is compared with the quantity and cycle time.

Any release of a job to these four machines is in scope — not only the scenarios pictured here. Not covered: scheduling across machines, tooling and fixture design, other machines and processes, and the machine's own safety interlocks, which stay with the machine controller. All machines, limits and rules are fictional; the parts and customers are fictional.

The AI production-planning agentPicks the next job and releases it to a machine from the plant's records, and says it is ready.
Predictika validatorChecks every rule at once and returns the verdict, each finding, and the computed figures.

6 scenarios in 3 groups · each group runs from the agent’s first attempt to the outcome · click one to switch

What the agent proposes

The AI production-planning agent says

Illustrative agent statement. The validator receives the structured request below.

Proposing agent: AI production-planning agent (scripted)

Before sending, the agent must call Recorded run

Predictika validator


      
Waiting for the call.

Where a typical release check gets it wrong

Click to expand

Our assessment of what a typical release check in an ERP or MES (a capability table per machine, a few validation rules and a manual look at the maintenance calendar) does with the same cases. It is a judgment about effort and reliability, not a claim that nothing can be built.

What the validator caughtTypical plant-floor release checkPredictika
A calibration limit that depends on the toleranceOnly with workarounds
The same machine is fit at a loose tolerance and not at a tight one: under 20 microns the calibration limit drops from 180 days to 90. A fixed per-machine table cannot say that; it takes a rule per tolerance band.
Calibration age is checked against the limit for this tolerance and this machine on every call.
A fix that opens the next problemOnly with workarounds
Moving a five-axis part to the 5-axis mill clears the axis and material findings but needs a level 3 operator, and the calibration age and tool life are that machine's, not the old one's. A check that runs as the job is saved shows one error at a time.
Machine, operator, tools, calibration and certification are checked together, so the corrected release is checked as a whole.
Tools against the length of the runOnly with care
Tool life left has to be compared with quantity times cycle time, and the cycle time is on the routing, not on the release. Someone has to remember to look.
The run time is computed from quantity and cycle time and compared with the tool life on every call.
Programs, shifts and proof partsOnly with care
A program that has not run before releases one part only and never runs on a lights-out shift. Each is a separate rule that interacts with the quantity and the shift.
Program, quantity and shift are checked together.
The run time the agent statesOnly with workarounds
The figure an agent types into a release never reaches a check in the MES; nothing compares it with the job data.
The stated run time is a field the validator receives and compares with its own.
Approvals that depend on who must signOnly with workarounds
Maintenance falling due mid-run, a long unattended run and taking the machine from a running job each go to a different person; routing is manual.
Each approval is its own finding, with the reason, and a person must approve before the release executes.
Every problem returned in one answerOnly with workarounds
Rules tend to fire as the release is saved, so a planner fixes one error and meets the next.
All findings come back together, whatever order the choices arrived in.

What this validator catches: findings from its test cases

Click to expand

Every rule is checked on every call, in any order the choices arrive; one problem never hides another. Blocking findings stop the job; approval findings need a person to sign off; everything else is computed.

1The fixture for this job is not at the machine; the job cannot be clamped and run until it is.
2The part is 760 mm long, more than the 750 mm the selected machine takes.
3The part weighs 810 kg, more than the 800 kg the selected machine carries.
4The part needs 5 axes of motion; the selected machine has 3.
5The drawing asks for a tolerance of 9 microns; the selected machine holds 10 microns at best.
6Titanium runs only on the 5-axis mill and the lathe, which have through-spindle coolant; the 3-axis mill and the laser cutter do not.
7The selected machine was calibrated 91 days ago; for this tolerance and machine the limit is 90 days.
8The run needs 610 machine minutes, but the tools loaded have 600 minutes of life left.
9The operator is qualified to level 1; the selected machine needs level 2.
10Medical and aerospace work needs the material certification for the lot on file before it is released.
11A program that has not run before may release one proof part only; this release is for 5 parts.
12An unproven program cannot run unattended; it needs an operator at the machine.
13The release states a run time of 150 minutes, but the quantity and cycle time give 200 minutes.
14The run needs 200 machine minutes but the machine is due for preventive maintenance in 120 minutes; the maintenance supervisor approves running through it or scheduling it first.
15The lights-out run is 370 machine minutes, over the 360 minutes a planner may leave unattended; the production manager signs off.
16The release takes the machine from a job already running; the production supervisor approves the change.

Scenarios and results

Click to expand

The recorded result of the validator for each scenario on this page: the request the AI agent sent, the verdict, and every finding, in the order they appear above.

1. Titanium impeller: Aerospace titanium impellers released to the 3-axis mill

The agent's request. Please release 12 titanium grade 5 parts for aerospace work to the 3-axis mill, on the day shift, in the next free slot. Each part is 280 mm long, weighs 35 kg and needs 5 axes of motion, to a tolerance of 8 microns, and takes 95 minutes on the machine. The program has run before. The operator is at level 2. The release states a run time of 1,140 minutes. It is ready to go.

Verdict: Blocked.

  • Part needs more axes than the machine has. The part needs 5 axes of motion; the selected machine has 3.
  • Tolerance tighter than the machine holds. The drawing asks for a tolerance of 8 microns; the selected machine holds 10 microns at best.
  • Material not cut on this machine. Titanium runs only on the 5-axis mill and the lathe, which have through-spindle coolant; the 3-axis mill and the laser cutter do not.
  • Machine calibration too old for the tolerance. The selected machine was calibrated 120 days ago; for this tolerance and machine the limit is 90 days.
  • Tools will not last the run. The run needs 1,140 machine minutes, but the tools loaded have 900 minutes of life left.
  • Material certification not on file. Medical and aerospace work needs the material certification for the lot on file before it is released.

2. Titanium impeller: The agent resubmits after fixing the errors

The agent's request. Please release 12 titanium grade 5 parts for aerospace work to the 5-axis mill, on the day shift, in the next free slot. Each part is 280 mm long, weighs 35 kg and needs 5 axes of motion, to a tolerance of 8 microns, and takes 95 minutes on the machine. The program has run before. The operator is at level 3. The release states a run time of 1,140 minutes. It is ready to go.

Verdict: Allowed.

  • Run summary. 12 parts need 1,140 machine minutes; the tools have 1,500 minutes of life left and preventive maintenance is due in 300 hours.

3. Valve body: Medical stainless valve bodies, a new program, a full lot, lights out

The agent's request. Please release 80 stainless steel 304 parts for medical device work to the CNC lathe, on the lights-out shift, taking the machine from the job now running. Each part is 120 mm long, weighs 6 kg and needs 2 axes of motion, to a tolerance of 12 microns, and takes 9 minutes on the machine. The program has not run before. The operator is at level 2. The release states a run time of 720 minutes. It is ready to go.

Verdict: Blocked.

  • Fixture not ready. The fixture for this job is not at the machine; the job cannot be clamped and run until it is.
  • New program released for more than one part. A program that has not run before may release one proof part only; this release is for 80 parts.
  • Unproven program on a lights-out shift. An unproven program cannot run unattended; it needs an operator at the machine.
  • Long unattended run. The lights-out run is 720 machine minutes, over the 360 minutes a planner may leave unattended; the production manager signs off.
  • Job displaces a running job. The release takes the machine from a job already running; the production supervisor approves the change.

4. Valve body: The agent resubmits after fixing the errors

The agent's request. Please release 1 stainless steel 304 parts for medical device work to the CNC lathe, on the day shift, taking the machine from the job now running. Each part is 120 mm long, weighs 6 kg and needs 2 axes of motion, to a tolerance of 12 microns, and takes 9 minutes on the machine. The program has not run before. The operator is at level 2. The release states a run time of 9 minutes. It is ready to go.

Verdict: Needs approval.

  • Job displaces a running job. The release takes the machine from a job already running; the production supervisor approves the change.
  • Run summary. 1 parts need 9 machine minutes; the tools have 900 minutes of life left and preventive maintenance is due in 100 hours.

5. Plate nest: Steel plate nests released to the laser cutter

The agent's request. Please release 40 steel 1018 parts for general industrial work to the laser cutter, on the day shift, in the next free slot. Each part is 3,200 mm long, weighs 640 kg and needs 2 axes of motion, to a tolerance of 150 microns, and takes 11 minutes on the machine. The program has run before. The operator is at level 1. The release states a run time of 420 minutes. It is ready to go.

Verdict: Blocked.

  • Part longer than the machine takes. The part is 3,200 mm long, more than the 3,000 mm the selected machine takes.
  • Part heavier than the machine carries. The part weighs 640 kg, more than the 600 kg the selected machine carries.
  • Stated run time differs from the job data. The release states a run time of 420 minutes, but the quantity and cycle time give 440 minutes.

6. Plate nest: The agent resubmits after fixing the errors

The agent's request. Please release 40 steel 1018 parts for general industrial work to the laser cutter, on the day shift, in the next free slot. Each part is 2,900 mm long, weighs 560 kg and needs 2 axes of motion, to a tolerance of 150 microns, and takes 11 minutes on the machine. The program has run before. The operator is at level 1. The release states a run time of 440 minutes. It is ready to go.

Verdict: Allowed.

  • Run summary. 40 parts need 440 machine minutes; the tools have 500 minutes of life left and preventive maintenance is due in 90 hours.

Narration transcript

Click to expand

The text of the narrated walkthrough, step by step.

  1. Welcome to a demo of Predictika's Validator. An AI production-planning agent picks the next job and releases it to a machine, using the plant's own records: the machine and its calibration and maintenance, the tools loaded, the operator and shift, and more. Before it goes out, the agent sends the release to Predictika, which checks it against a declarative model of what those records say and returns a verdict, every reason and the figures it computed.
  2. I will start with the first request by the agent.
  3. The agent says. Please release 12 titanium grade 5 parts for aerospace work to the 3-axis mill, on the day shift, in the next free slot. Each part is 280 mm long, weighs 35 kg and needs 5 axes of motion, to a tolerance of 8 microns, and takes 95 minutes on the machine. The rest of the request is on screen. The release states a run time of 1,140 minutes.
  4. Before it goes out, the agent calls the validator.
  5. Blocked, with six findings, all in one answer. The part needs 5 axes of motion; the selected machine has 3. The drawing asks for a tolerance of 8 microns; the selected machine holds 10 microns at best. Titanium runs only on the 5-axis mill and the lathe, which have through-spindle coolant; the 3-axis mill and the laser cutter do not. The other three are on screen.
  6. The validator returned six blocking findings in one answer. A check that reads one field at a time would pass most of this; it shows only when the choices in the job are checked against each other.
  7. What this shows: for a calibration limit that depends on the tolerance, a plant-floor release check can do this only with workarounds.
  8. Now the agent resubmits.
  9. The corrected request. It changes the machine to 5-axis mill, the operator level to 3, the material certification to on file, the tool life left to 1,500 and the days since the machine was calibrated to 40.
  10. It calls the validator again.
  11. This time the validator clears it.
  12. All six earlier findings are cleared, and the validator's figure matches the job.
  13. Six problems caught in one call, fixed in one pass, and a clean job. That is the value of Predictika's validator: catching mistakes before they reach the machine. Now you can try the other scenarios yourself.