Predictika · Custom-part job quotes drafted from plant records

An AI quoting agent's custom-part job quote, checked before it goes to the customer

An AI quoting agent reads a customer's request for a custom machined or fabricated part and drafts the job quote from the plant's own records: the process, material, finish, certification, the cost build-up with its markup, and the lead time. Before it goes out, the agent sends it to Predictika, which checks it against a declarative model of what the plant's records say and returns a verdict, every reason and the figures it computed.

Scope: Custom-part job quotes at a precision job shop: CNC milling, CNC turning, laser and brake, weld fabrication; what the request must state, process limits, material and finish pairings, industry certification, cost build-up, lead time and approvals. See everything this validator covers

This validator models one job quote for one custom part design at a fictional precision job shop, not just the scenarios shown below. The shop, its rates and its rules are fictional stand-ins for what a real plant keeps in its job-cost records, machine capability sheets and quality procedures.

  • What the request must state — a material grade and a tolerance. A quote cannot be costed or scheduled without them, so a request that leaves one out is stopped and the agent is told what to ask the customer.
  • Process limits — each of the four processes has a longest part it can take and a tightest tolerance it can hold; titanium is machined only.
  • Material, finish and industry rules — anodizing for aluminum, zinc plating for steel, passivation for stainless steel and titanium, no powder coat on titanium; aerospace work needs a first article inspection report, medical stainless parts must be passivated, titanium needs a material certification.
  • Cost build-up and lead time — material, machining, finishing, setup and certification, plus a markup that depends on the customer tier; the total and the standard lead time the quote states are compared with the validator's own. A job over $50,000, a need date earlier than the standard lead time, and a computed unit cost more than 30 percent above a similar past job each go to a person.

Any job quote that touches these processes and rules is in scope — not only the scenarios pictured here. Not covered: assemblies, tooling and fixtures, freight, taxes, volume discounts, and processes other than the four named. All rates, limits and rules are fictional; the customers and parts are fictional.

The AI quoting agentDrafts the job quote from the customer's request and the plant's records, and says it is ready.
Predictika validatorChecks every rule at once and returns the verdict, each finding, and the computed figures.

6 scenarios in 3 groups · each group runs from the agent’s first attempt to the outcome · click one to switch

What the agent proposes

The AI quoting agent says

Illustrative agent statement. The validator receives the structured request below.

Proposing agent: AI quoting agent (scripted)

Before sending, the agent must call Recorded run

Predictika validator


      
Waiting for the call.

Where rules-based CPQ gets it wrong

Click to expand

Our assessment of what a typical rules-based CPQ (product rules, price rules and validation rules, as in Salesforce CPQ) does with the same cases. It is a judgment about effort and reliability, not a claim that nothing can be built.

What the validator caughtTypical rules-based CPQPredictika
A request that leaves out a material or a toleranceOnly with workarounds
A quoting tool prices what it is given. A blank grade or a drawing with no tolerance has to be caught by a rule written for each field, and nothing tells the agent what to ask the customer.
A blank material or tolerance is stopped on every call, with the question the customer needs to answer.
Limits that depend on the process chosenOnly with care
Each of four processes has its own longest part and tightest tolerance, and titanium runs on two of them only; one rule per process per limit.
Part length, tolerance and material are checked against the chosen process together.
Finishes that depend on the materialOnly with care
Anodizing is for aluminum, zinc plating for steel, passivation for stainless steel and titanium, and powder coat is not run on titanium: a pairing matrix between two fields chosen on different lines.
The finish is checked against the material on every call.
Certification that depends on the industryOnly with workarounds
Aerospace work needs a first article report, medical stainless parts must be passivated and titanium needs a material certification. Fixing one changes the cost and the lead time, which can open the next problem.
Industry, certification, material and finish are checked together, and the cost and lead time are recomputed from the corrected route.
A total and a lead time that have to match the cost build-upOnly with workarounds
The total the agent typed can leave out the certification, apply the wrong customer tier's markup or forget the batch days, and nobody notices, because the quoting tool never receives it.
The total and lead time are computed from the route and compared with the figures the quote states.
Cost compared with a similar past jobOnly with workarounds
A person has to remember to look up the similar job; no rule can compare a new cost with one that lives in another system.
The similar job's unit cost is an input, and a computed cost more than 30 percent above it goes to a person.
Every problem returned in one answerOnly with workarounds
Rules tend to fire as the quote is saved, so a person often fixes one error and meets the next.
All findings come back together, whatever order the choices arrived in.

What this validator catches: findings from its test cases

Click to expand

Every rule is checked on every call, in any order the choices arrive; one problem never hides another. Blocking findings stop the quote; approval findings need a person to sign off; everything else is computed.

1The request does not state a material grade; the plant cannot cost or schedule the job until the customer confirms it.
2The drawing states no tolerance; the plant cannot confirm the process can hold it until the customer gives one.
3The part is 620 mm long, more than the 600 mm this process can take.
4The quote asks for a tolerance of 11 microns; the selected process holds 12 microns at best.
5Titanium is machined only; the plant does not laser cut, bend or weld it.
6The plant anodizes aluminum only, zinc plates steel only, passivates stainless steel and titanium only, and does not powder coat titanium.
7Aerospace work needs an AS9100 first article inspection report on the quote.
8Medical stainless steel parts must be passivated.
9Titanium is bought against a material certification, which must be on the quote.
10The quote states a total of $7,457.20, but the plant cost build-up with its markup gives $7,507.20.
11The quote states a lead time of 12 days, but the route, finish, certification and material on it give 15 days.
12The customer needs the parts in 10 days but the standard lead time is 15 days; expedited scheduling needs plant manager approval.
13The quote total is $58,305.00, above the 5,000,$0.00 that a salesperson may quote alone; the sales director signs off.
14The computed unit cost is $25.70, more than 30 percent above the $19.00 on the similar past job; a person confirms the difference before the quote goes out.

Scenarios and results

Click to expand

The recorded result of the validator for each scenario on this page: the request the AI agent sent, the verdict, and every finding, in the order they appear above.

1. Titanium actuator pin: Aerospace titanium actuator pins quoted on the mill

The agent's request. Please quote 150 CNC milled titanium grade 5 parts for aerospace work, each 250 mm long, to a tolerance of 11 microns, powder coated, with a material certification. Each part weighs 300 g and takes 30 minutes on the machine. The customer needs them in 45 days. The quote states a total of $11,443.20 and a standard lead time of 23 days. It is ready to send.

Verdict: Blocked.

  • Tolerance tighter than the process holds. The quote asks for a tolerance of 11 microns; the selected process holds 12 microns at best.
  • Finish not run on this material. The plant anodizes aluminum only, zinc plates steel only, passivates stainless steel and titanium only, and does not powder coat titanium.
  • Aerospace job without a first article report. Aerospace work needs an AS9100 first article inspection report on the quote.
  • Stated total differs from the cost build-up. The quote states a total of $11,443.20, but the plant cost build-up with its markup gives $12,121.60.
  • Stated lead time differs from the standard. The quote states a lead time of 23 days, but the route, finish, certification and material on it give 29 days.

2. Titanium actuator pin: The agent resubmits after fixing the errors

The agent's request. Please quote 150 CNC turned titanium grade 5 parts for aerospace work, each 250 mm long, to a tolerance of 11 microns, passivated, with an AS9100 first article inspection report. Each part weighs 300 g and takes 30 minutes on the machine. The customer needs them in 45 days. The quote states a total of $10,534.40 and a standard lead time of 30 days. It is ready to send.

Verdict: Allowed.

  • Cost build-up summary. The plant cost build-up gives a total of $10,534.40 for 150 parts with a standard lead time of 30 days.

3. Medical valve body: Medical stainless valve bodies from a request with no tolerance

The agent's request. Please quote 60 CNC milled stainless steel 304 parts for medical device work, each 140 mm long. Each part weighs 800 g and takes 40 minutes on the machine. The customer needs them in 14 days. The quote states a total of $5,779.44 and a standard lead time of 13 days. It is ready to send.

Verdict: Blocked.

  • Tolerance missing from the request. The drawing states no tolerance; the plant cannot confirm the process can hold it until the customer gives one.
  • Medical stainless part not passivated. Medical stainless steel parts must be passivated.
  • Cost well above the similar job. The computed unit cost is $64.80, more than 30 percent above the $48.00 on the similar past job; a person confirms the difference before the quote goes out.

4. Medical valve body: The agent resubmits after fixing the errors

The agent's request. Please quote 60 CNC milled stainless steel 304 parts for medical device work, each 140 mm long, to a tolerance of 25 microns, passivated. Each part weighs 800 g and takes 40 minutes on the machine. The customer needs them in 14 days. The quote states a total of $5,928.48 and a standard lead time of 17 days. It is ready to send.

Verdict: Needs approval.

  • Needed sooner than the standard lead time. The customer needs the parts in 14 days but the standard lead time is 17 days; expedited scheduling needs plant manager approval.
  • Cost well above the similar job. The computed unit cost is $66.60, more than 30 percent above the $48.00 on the similar past job; a person confirms the difference before the quote goes out.
  • Cost build-up summary. The plant cost build-up gives a total of $5,928.48 for 60 parts with a standard lead time of 17 days.

5. Aluminum enclosure: Six hundred aluminum electronics enclosures

The agent's request. Please quote 600 laser cut and bent aluminum 6061 parts for general industrial work, each 700 mm long, to a tolerance of 150 microns, zinc plated. Each part weighs 1,200 g and takes 8 minutes on the machine. The customer needs them in 40 days. The quote states a total of $11,328.00 and a standard lead time of 9 days. It is ready to send.

Verdict: Blocked.

  • Finish not run on this material. The plant anodizes aluminum only, zinc plates steel only, passivates stainless steel and titanium only, and does not powder coat titanium.
  • Stated total differs from the cost build-up. The quote states a total of $11,328.00, but the plant cost build-up with its markup gives $12,213.00.
  • Stated lead time differs from the standard. The quote states a lead time of 9 days, but the route, finish, certification and material on it give 14 days.

6. Aluminum enclosure: The agent resubmits after fixing the errors

The agent's request. Please quote 600 laser cut and bent aluminum 6061 parts for general industrial work, each 700 mm long, to a tolerance of 150 microns, anodized. Each part weighs 1,200 g and takes 8 minutes on the machine. The customer needs them in 40 days. The quote states a total of $13,537.80 and a standard lead time of 17 days. It is ready to send.

Verdict: Allowed.

  • Cost build-up summary. The plant cost build-up gives a total of $13,537.80 for 600 parts with a standard lead time of 17 days.

Narration transcript

Click to expand

The text of the narrated walkthrough, step by step.

  1. Welcome to a demo of Predictika's Validator. An AI quoting agent reads a customer's request for a custom machined or fabricated part and drafts the job quote from the plant's own records: the process, material, finish, and more. Before it goes out, the agent sends it to Predictika, which checks it against a declarative model of what the plant's records say and returns a verdict, every reason and the figures it computed.
  2. I will start with the first request by the agent.
  3. The agent says. Please quote 150 CNC milled titanium grade 5 parts for aerospace work, each 250 mm long, to a tolerance of 11 microns, powder coated, with a material certification. Each part weighs 300 g and takes 30 minutes on the machine. The rest of the request is on screen. The quote states a total of $11,443.20 and a standard lead time of 23 days.
  4. Before it goes out, the agent calls the validator.
  5. Blocked, with five findings, all in one answer. The quote asks for a tolerance of 11 microns; the selected process holds 12 microns at best. The plant anodizes aluminum only, zinc plates steel only, passivates stainless steel and titanium only, and does not powder coat titanium. Aerospace work needs an AS9100 first article inspection report on the quote. The other two are on screen.
  6. The validator returned five blocking findings in one answer. A check that reads one field at a time would pass most of this; it shows only when the choices in the quote are checked against each other and against the stated total.
  7. What this shows: for a total and a lead time that have to match the cost build-up, a rules-based CPQ can do this only with workarounds.
  8. Now the agent resubmits.
  9. The corrected request. It changes the process to CNC turning, the finish to passivated, the certification to AS9100 first article inspection report, the stated total to $10,534.40 and the stated standard lead time to 30 days.
  10. It calls the validator again.
  11. This time the validator clears it.
  12. The validator also returns the line-item quote. It starts with Titanium grade 5 and CNC turning; the other four lines are on screen.
  13. All five earlier findings are cleared, and the validator's total, $10,534.40, matches the quote.
  14. Five problems caught in one call, fixed in one pass, and a clean $10,534.40 quote. That is the value of Predictika's validator: catching mistakes before they reach the customer. Now you can try the other scenarios yourself.